Sustain: To keep in the current state.

Sustainability Is Not Enough

by Kasturika | | 15 min read

Sustainable design. Sustainable fashion. Sustainable living. We often hear these terms in marketing campaigns and popular media. But what does sustainability mean and why does pioneer of User Experience Design Don Norman think that sustainability shouldn’t be our goal when we design? Watch the video to find out.

Show Hide video transcript
  1. Transcript loading...

As Don Norman emphasizes in this video, how we communicate is as important as what we communicate. Just as the idea of sustainability doesn't capture the magnitude of the work ahead of us, a 2-degree increase in global temperature doesn't convey the gravity of our situation. We must show how that slight increase has disastrous consequences for millions—from extreme drought to devastating hurricanes.

What Are Viable Alternatives to Planned Obsolescence?

Planned obsolescence is the practice of deliberately shortening the life of a product to force people to buy replacements. Companies use three techniques to make their products obsolete:

  • Breakdown: Products that people cannot repair easily, or are extremely expensive to repair because the parts are exclusively available in select places or are expensive become obsolete through breakdown.

  • Progress: Products that are not designed to be upgraded easily, or new technology that is not backward compatible with older devices makes the older devices obsolete.

  • Fashion: When marketers pitch a certain look as new or fashionable, people with older (or previous generation) products feel they have outdated products. Even if these are in perfect working condition, people seek replacements.

One of the prime examples of planned obsolescence are smartphones and laptops that become obsolete within a year or two.

Case Study: Smartphones

Apple’s iPhones set the trend for “unibody” cases that did not have detachable batteries. Users can go to a service center and have the phone batteries replaced. But beyond that, the phone cannot be upgraded.

Further, Apple only allows certain retailers to do work on their products, and oftentimes voids warranties if anyone else modifies them. This forces the consumer to buy a new device instead of repairing the original device. 

As opposed to Apple’s single-body devices, assembled desktop PCs allow users to switch out different parts of the machine to incrementally upgrade its performance without replacing the entire unit. Some companies have taken steps to make their devices as reusable and upgradeable as possible.

Cross-section of a modular smartphone

The Fairphone brings the assembled Desktop PC model to smartphones. Their website claims, “You don’t need to be an expert to swap out the battery or display. No part of Fairphone 4 is glued shut, so you can choose to easily repair it yourself with a standard screwdriver.”

© Fairphone, Fair Use

Fairphone is just one example of a company that looks beyond selling a product. There are limitless opportunities for such a model across every industry.

Show Hide video transcript
  1. Transcript loading...

Apple has faced criticisms for its design decisions and the e-waste that it encourages. To Apple’s credit, it has tried to reduce its wasteful practices. For example, the company has a trade-in policy that lets buyers get a new device at a discount. The company refurbishes the older device and sells it through its distribution chain. Apple also ensures all its operating systems are backward compatible, so that everyone enjoys the latest OS, even if they have an older device. Coupled with long-lasting hardware, the company pitches itself as a planet-friendly organization that reduces waste. 

The Take Away

Sustainability means to maintain the current state. As the world continues to produce waste, landfills and carbon-emissions-saturated air have disturbed the ecosystem of the planet. If we were to continue to maintain the current state, the future would be bleak. In other words, we cannot sustain the unsustainable.

Businesses and designers must change the way we design and our business models. We must think of ways to make products repairable and long-lasting. More importantly, we must think beyond just selling products. We must consider every component of the system—where and how we get our raw materials, how can we make them as modular as possible, and how do we bring back older products and disassemble them to put them back into the manufacturing process?

A systems approach also allows companies to reduce costs and explore multiple revenue streams (for example, through the sale of spare parts).

References and Where to Learn More

Don Norman covers sustainability (and why it isn’t enough) in more detail in his book Design for a Better World: Meaningful, Sustainable, Humanity Centered.

Additional resources from the book “Design for a Better World” are available at the Resources for DBW website.

See this essay by Don Norman in which he elaborates his stance on why recycling isn’t the best solution for sustainability on
Recycling: A poor solution to the wrong problem: An essay in two parts 

Self-described “Apple holic” Jonny Evans analyzes Apple's second-user smartphone business.

It’s not possible to paint Apple’s sustainability claims and practices in one color. Here is a holistic, multi-layered analysis:
Apple Isn't as Green as It Pretends to Be: Here's Why

Open Access - Link to us!

We believe in Open Access and the democratization of knowledge. Unfortunately, world class educational materials such as this page are normally hidden behind paywalls or in expensive textbooks.

If you want this to change, , link to us, or join us to help us democratize design knowledge!