Marc Hassenzahl explains the fascinating concept of User Experience and Experience Design. Commentaries by Don Norman, Eric Reiss, Mark Blythe, and Whitney Hess
User Experience and Experience Design !
The concept of Multiple Intelligences was first formulated by Howard Gardner in his 1983 book, Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences. Whereas linguistic and logical-mathematical intelligences are centrally addressed and nurtured by the three Rs of traditional education, other forms of intelligence, including musical, bodily-kinesthetic, and spatial, provide alternative means of accessing knowledge, according to Gardner’s scheme. Gardner’s theory catalogues the different styles of learning that students bring to the classroom. The theory can also be applied to the forms of reasoning that people of all ages use in any scene of information retrieval and intellectual exchange, from understanding prescription bottles, package labels and cookbooks to navigating maps, magazines, and web sites.
Verbal communication abilities
Mathematical and logical skills
Performance, composition and appreciation of musical patterns
Using the body and bodily movement (i.e., sports and dance) to solve problems or understand the environment
Ability to navigate space, understand, map and apply spatial patterns
The skills of the classic “people person,” who understands human motivation and behavior and uses this understanding to further personal goals (in sales, ministry, counseling, politics, etc.)
Socratic capacity to “know thyself,” and to use self-knowledge to organize your life
Other candidates for multiple intelligences include “naturalist,” “spiritual,” “existential,” and “moral,” but have not been formally included in Gardner’s template.
Gardner’s background is in psychology (which he studied as an undergraduate under luminaries that included psychoanalyst Erik Erikson) and education (he received his doctorate in Education from Harvard in 1971, with a dissertation on style sensitivity in children). As a graduate student and then later as a scholar and researcher, Gardner worked in Project Zero, which studies arts education. He now holds the title of Hobbs Professor of Cognition and Education at the Harvard Graduate School of Education.
The main impact of “Multiple Intelligences” has been on the field of education, especially the progressive pedagogy associated with the work of John Dewey. Much of the MI approach involves applying the underlying concepts and techniques developed in arts education to the teaching of academic subjects. In classrooms, employing “Multiple Intelligences” means trying to engage different styles of learning in order to maximize educational success, intellectual growth, and enthusiasm for learning among diverse learners, often by introducing the arts (music, drawing, dance) into the study of literature, history, or math. This concept is especially relevant to urban schools and to students with learning disabilities. Such students may be underdeveloped verbally or mathematically, but often have skills and aptitudes in musical, athletic, or interpersonal realms that can be tapped by teachers, parents, and other educators. Classrooms and even schools can be redesigned to reflect and encourage these different forms of learning (by creating open spaces for kinesthetic activities, for example). The rise of the computer in the classroom has provided a new tool for integrating multiple intelligences via streaming video, mp3 files, image galleries, and self-knowledge survey tools.
Gardner also extended some of his insights beyond formal education in the GoodWork project, which promotes “work that is at once excellent in technical quality and at the same time responsive to the needs and wishes of the broader community in which it takes place.” The project has studied “good work” in journalism, business, and theatre.
In the area of interactive design, the theory of multiple intelligences can further the enterprise of building information landscapes navigable not only by those with linguistic or mathematical fluency, but also by the visually, musically, or spatially inclined. Many magazines are designed to be consumed by different kinds of readers: those looking for a good story or in-depth coverage (“linguistic intelligence”), those who seek tabulations of facts or comparative data (“mathematical intelligence”), those who are stimulated and informed by pictures (“spatial intelligence”), or those who like rating their behaviors and values through surveys (“intra-personal intelligence”). Web sites can also use design to stimulate and satisfy multiple intelligences. Blogs exercise interpersonal as well as verbal intelligence. Navigation tools often combine visual, aural, and verbal cues and feedback mechanisms. Multimedia presentations can enhance comprehension and recall of challenging materials.
Academic psychology, including the scientific study of intelligence, has not embraced Gardner’s account of human cognition and learning, partly because his theories are difficult to test empirically. See Smith's entry in the encyclopedia of informal education, 'Howard Gardner and multiple intelligences', for a survey of the debate and for an especially helpful history of his contributions in context.
Despite these important criticisms, practitioners in the applied fields of teaching (K-12 and even college) and design (interaction design, print, internet, etc) can benefit from an expanded picture of human capacity and a reminder of the various ways in which minds can be engaged.
Gardner (1999) is a useful review of Gardner's theory and discussion of issues and additions.
Project Zero: Arts education initiative at Harvard University where Gardner first engaged in educational research, and now participates as its most prominent researcher.
The Good Work Project: The project 'researches how leading professionals carry out work that is of high quality and socially responsible' and is part of a collaboration with Howard Gardner.
Self-test your intelligences (Learning Disabilities Pride) at http://www.ldpride.net/learningstyles.MI.htm
Technology and Multiple Intelligences in the Classroom at http://eduscapes.com/tap/topic68.htm
Give us your opinion! Do you have any comments/additions
that you would like other visitors to see?
Gardner, Howard (1989): To Open Minds: Chinese clues to the dilemma of contemporary education. New York, Basic Books
Gardner, Howard (1985): The Mind's New Science: A History of the Cognitive Revolution. New York, Basic Books
Gardner, Howard (1991): The Unschooled Mind: How Children Think and How Schools Should Teach. New York, Basic Books
Gardner, Howard (1999b): The Disciplined Mind: Beyond Facts and Standardized Tests. New York, Basic Books
Gardner, Howard (1999a): Intelligence Reframed: Multiple Intelligences for the 21st Century. New York, Basic Books
Gardner, Howard (1983): Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences. New York, Basic Books
Smith, Mark K. (2005). Howard Gardner and multiple intelligences. Retrieved 29 November 2005 from Infed.org, the encyclopedia of informal education: http://www.infed.org/thinkers/gardner.htm