May 24

For a list of all the ways technology has failed to improve the quality of life, please press three.

-- Alice Kahn

 
 

Featured chapter

Read the fascinating history of Wearable Computing, told by its father, Steve Mann

Read Steve's chapter !

 
 

Help us help you!

 
 

James Kornell

Add description
Add publication

Publications by James Kornell (bibliography)

 what's this?
1991
 
Edit | Del

McCloskey, Brian P., Geiwitz, James and Kornell, James (1991): Empirical Comparisons of Knowledge Acquisition Techniques. In: Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 35th Annual Meeting 1991. pp. 268-272.

The degree to which a knowledge-acquisition technique (KAT) extracts useful information from a human expert varies, in large part, as a function of the type of expert system being developed. The present study employed two KATs, ARK (a structured-interview technique) and Repertory Grid (a similarity-judgment technique), to elicit knowledge from U.S. Army helicopter pilots with expertise in mission planning. The resultant knowledge bases were compared in terms of their applicability to two tasks: attack route evaluation and attack route planning. The study revealed important qualitative and quantitative differences in the knowledge bases elicited by the two KATs. The Repertory Grid method elicited dimensions with which the efficiency of attack routes could be classified and, in general, appears to be well-suited for use in development of "convergent" expert systems intended to perform tasks involving categorization or evaluation. In contrast, ARK elicited procedural information (e.g., goals, strategies, and rules) with which route planning could be performed, and appears better suited for obtaining information to be used in the development of "divergent" expert systems designed to conduct tasks involving planning or scheduling. The results have implications for the selection of KATS and the design of knowledge-elicitation sessions, and suggest that further analyses of the knowledge-acquisition process be conducted.

© All rights reserved McCloskey et al. and/or Human Factors Society

 
Add publication
Show this list on your homepage
 
 

Join the technology elite and advance:

 
1.

Your career

 
2.

Your network

 
 3.

Your skills

 
 
 
 
 
 

Changes to this page (author)

20 Feb 2010: Modified
26 Jun 2007: Added

Page Information

Page maintainer: The Editorial Team
URL: http://www.interaction-design.org/references/authors/james_kornell.html
May 24

For a list of all the ways technology has failed to improve the quality of life, please press three.

-- Alice Kahn

 
 

Featured chapter

Read the fascinating history of Wearable Computing, told by its father, Steve Mann

Read Steve's chapter !

 
 

Help us help you!